Hi Gerrit, I'm glad you are interested in this aspect. There are 6 types of Oxygen track changes: https://www.oxygenxml.com/doc/versions/22.1/ug-editor/topics/track-changes-f... The insert track changes do not nest one in another, so you will never have an insert track change inside another, same for the combination of insert and delete track changes, they are not hierarchical, they are intervals which do not intersect each other. So your XSLT should cover most cases for insertions and deletions as oxy_insert_start and oxy_insert_end processing instructions would usually be siblings (surrounding wellformed XML content). The surround change for example does not surround well formed XML content, it just surrounds the start tag. The attribute change is just a processing instruction before the XML start tag. The comment and color highlights on the other side can nest one in another and can intersect in any way. So these are nasty, you can create elements for a comment start and end but you cannot create a wrapper element over the entire content spanned by a comment or a color highlight. You need some kind of a stack of processing instructions in the XSLT to know where a comment starts and where it ends. You can also reply to a change or to a comment in Oxygen and this will generate extra comment changes which are threaded. For DocBook 5 Oxygen ships with a bundled transformation scenario for producing PDF with track changes, it's build file is located in: OXYGEN_INSTALL_DIR/frameworks/docbook/xsl/fo-oxy-ct/build.xml We also make available with an Apache 2.0 license the XSLT stylesheets we use for DITA publishing, stylesheets which with small changes should also work for DocBook HTML or PDF: https://github.com/oxygenxml/dita-classic-pdf-review/tree/master/com.oxygenx... From what I remember our way of handling this is to create from each processing instruction start or end an equivalent XML element in a custom Oxygen namespace, then to match all text() nodes, the template is here: https://github.com/oxygenxml/dita-classic-pdf-review/blob/master/com.oxygenx...

<xsl:template match="text()" priority="100"> and if there are change elements which are around the text, surround each text fragment in a highlight element. So we avoid surrounding entire pieces of XML in annotation elements, we just surround each individual piece of text.

Regards, Radu Radu Coravu Oxygen XML Editor On 8/17/20 10:21 PM, Imsieke, Gerrit, le-tex wrote:

Apologies for cross-posting. Please think about whether the answer is most relevant to only one of both mailings lists before replying to both.

I recently wanted to render a large book (DocBook 5.1) that was copy-edited in oXygen author mode and that contained the corresponding processing instructions, and I wanted to render it with the Ant-based FO scenario that displays changes. But for some reason that I could not really fathom, neither this FOP scenario nor the default PDF rendering scenario produced results, with different error messages. Increasing oXygen’s or Ant’s heap space to insane amounts didn’t improve the situation.

Anyway, I didn’t need a PDF; HTML would be fine, too, so I decided to add an oXygen change markup renderer to Norm’s brand new xslTNG stylesheets, https://github.com/docbook/xslTNG

There’s a pull request to xslTNG where I asked Norm to merge it into xslTNG (https://github.com/docbook/xslTNG/pull/67). But since it has been hardly tested on many documents, Norm is hesitant to merge it, and I’d like to collect some user feedback first.

I’d like to ask you to test it on your DocBook files that have been enhanced with change markup in oXygen’s author mode. The patched renderer is at https://github.com/gimsieke/xslTNG/tree/oxy-markup. You probably need Gradle or something to build it yourself, but you can use the latest release (https://github.com/docbook/xslTNG/releases) and replace the changed files (https://github.com/docbook/xslTNG/pull/67/files).

Or you can just run the stylesheet https://github.com/gimsieke/xslTNG/blob/oxy-markup/src/main/xslt/transforms/... standalone, render the resulting DocBook to HTML and define the CSS classes .oxy_insert and .oxy_delete to naybe color:green and color:red, respectively.

Please let me know whether it works in principle or whether there are bugs or missing features. Also whether there’s already another stylesheet somewhere in place that is supposed to render the oXygen change markup PIs.

Gerrit _______________________________________________ oXygen-user mailing list oXygen-user@oxygenxml.com https://www.oxygenxml.com/mailman/listinfo/oxygen-user