Hello, Robert Nagle wrote:

So here is my understanding based on what you said: When the files are in a project, the xpr project file is an xml file containing the customizations specific to your project. That includes names of files, and the specifics of any customized transformation which you have added for the specific project. So you could find your customizations here.

The transformed files don't have to be in the project. The scenarios are saved in the .xpr project file when you select the radio button Project Scenarios in the dialog Configure Transformation Scenario: http://www.oxygenxml.com/doc/ug-oxygen/transformation-scenarios-sharing.html

so docbook5.framework stores all the scenarios which will show up for the docbook5 global scenarios list?

docbook5.framework stores only the scenarios displayed on the Transformation tab of the Document Type dialog when the DocBook 5 document type is edited: http://www.oxygenxml.com/doc/ug-oxygen/dg-complex-customization-tutorial.htm... These scenarios have a yellow key icon when they are displayed in the dialog Configure Transformation Scenario together with the global scenarios as you can see in the screenshot in the above section of the User Manual.

My main concerns here are 1)being able to find the xslt customizations after I make them (in the event that i need to run them via command line or use another application),

Reusing a scenario in other application or from a command line is not possible with the current method of scenario persistence applied in Oxygen. It is a request for a future version.

2)being able to use the same xslt customizations for a second project if I create another docbook project and

If the scenario with your customizations is saved at document type level just make sure the document type is enabled in the table available from Preferences -> Document Type Association. It does not matter what project you load in the Project view. If it is saved at project level make sure you have the scenario saved at global level and transfer it to project level for each DocBook project that you create by switching from Global Scenarios to Project Scenarios in the dialog Configure Transformation Scenario.

3))not accidentally deleting or altering the default transforms.

The scenarios of a document type can be edited only by the Developer role set in Preferences -> Document Type Association. The scenarios of a project are deleted when the scenario is modified and the project file saved. In both cases you can store the scenario on a version control system (CVS, SVN, etc) by saving the .framework file or the .xpr project file in the version control system.

I guess the general solution is to use projects as much as possible.

I'm looking here http://www.oxygenxml.com/doc/ug-oxygen/preferences-sharing.html

I'm not quite sure what you are doing when you go to Configure Transformation Scenario and switch from GLOBAL SCENARIOS to PROJECT SCENARIOS and vice versa. Regardless of whether I select GLOBAL or PROJECT, they both show the same scenarios (the read-only scenarios indicated by a key icon and a customized scenario I have created myself). Is this normal?

(My guess: I originally created them with GLOBAL SCENARIOS checked, and so that means they appear in the PROJECT SCENARIOS tab as well. But the rev).

The switch from Global to Project duplicates all the current global scenarios at project level and after that any scenario modification is stored at project level. The reverse switch removes all the project scenarios from the project file and reloads the old copy of the set of global scenarios with the parameters that they had at that time. The global scenarios are stored in the user preferences in a subfolder of the user home folder so they are reloaded from there.

If I try to delete a custom scenario from either Project Scenarios or Global Scenarios and press ok, I see that the scenario i have tried to delete has not been deleted. What do I need to do to accomplish this?

If you press OK in the dialog Configure Transformation Scenario the scenario is deleted. It does not matter if it is at project level or global level. If you deleted a project level scenario and after that revert to Global Scenarios the old set of scenarios is reloaded which includes a copy of the deleted scenario. It is the global scenario that remains, the project scenario was deleted.

Reading through the archives, I see that you are trying to rework the UI for the transformations dialog. That would probably be a good thing. The thing that confuses me is why the same scenarios appear when you have PROJECT SCENARIOS checked as when would have GLOBAL SCENARIOS.

The switch from Global Scenarios to Project Scenarios is made with the purpose of sharing the current set of global scenarios through the project file. If you want to share only a subset of the global scenarios or customized versions of the global scenarios feel free to customize the project scenarios after the switch. Regards, Sorin